Limongi 1997, stable or unstable lipset 1959, or is reflected in single. If they can take the high road to economic development, they can keep their political houses in. Examine the relationship between the democracy and economic growth in 30 subsaharan african counties, support the lipset hypothesis, use the real gdp granger to explore the cause of democracy and an increase in gdp results in an improvement in democracy. Lipsets law revisited1 prepared by ghada fayad, robert h. Project muse the seymour martin lipset lecture on democracy. An overwhelming proportion of the literature fails to distinguish between the processes of democratization and democratic. It appears reasonable to answer the first question affirmatively. Economic development and political legitimacy in 1959 became one of the most cited and perhaps controversial article in social sciences diamond, 1992. Tan since seymour martin lipset s seminal work on the socioeconomic prerequisites of democracy, a substantial number of social scientists has theorized and empirically tested theories about the relationship between democracy and economic develop. Economic development and political legitimacy1 volume 53 issue 1 seymour martin lipset skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users. He concluded that economic development is a causal mechanism for democratization. The primary purpose of this paper is to show audience that there. Democracy and development is democracy inherently a good thing.
Development, democratization, and democratic deepening. Relationship between the democracy and economic growth. The social requisites of democracy revisited 1993 presidential address seymour martin lipset george mason university in this paper i discuss the factors and processes affecting the prospects for the institu tionalization of democracy throughout the world. Lastly, i conclude that the controversy over development and democracy is inconclusive and will be continuing. Lipset seymour martin some social requisites of democracy economic development from developmen dva1501 at university of south africa. The literature on the relationship between economic development and democracy is varied and complex. Introduction would economic development lead to democracy or democracy generate economic development. Decomposing overall income per capita into its resource and nonresource. Some scholars argue that economic growth drives social mobilization, which in turn leads to political mobilization and eventually regime change to democracy lipset, 1959 andneedler, 1967. Economic development is correlated with many other trends, and one or more of those may be the causal mechanism that accounts for the apparent relationship p.
The most influential article is the seymour martin lipset s thesis first proposed in 1959, which posited a causal. In contrast, democracies that arise without prior economic development sometimes because they are imposed by former colonial powers or international organi. On this basis, the note highlights the intrinsic value of the democratic process. Lipset argued that economic development changes the relationship between state and society to favor the emergence and maintenance of. Jan 11, 2007 among the most influential are lipset s analysis of support for nazism as middleclass radicalism, and his chapter linking democracy to economic development originally published as an article in.
Economic liberalization, it was predicted, would lead to political liberalization and, eventually, democracy. We use principle component analysis for a composite measure for economic development. The note then goes on to assess some key causal linkages between democracy and development in section iii, discussing in particular modernisation theory and the emergence of democracy. The relationship between economic development and democracy has dominated academic discourses for. Jan 15, 2010 in some social requisites of democracy, lipset 1959 emphasizes the strong relationship between capitalist economic development and the prospects for democracy, an argument to which he returned in his asa presidential address. Bates, and anke hoeffler authorized for distribution by tim callen december 2012 abstract we revisit lipsets law, which posits a positive and significant relationship between income and democracy. Lipset hypothesised that, together, the changing social. It has been supported and contested, revised and extended, buried and resuscitated. On the other hand, it seems fair to question whether such linearity is validly demonstrated.
Seymour martin lipset s 1959 essay on some social requisites of democracy. Using dynamic and heterogeneous panel data estimation techniques, we find a significant and negative relationship between income and democracy. We argue that economic development favours the electoralaspect of democracy while. In contrast, democracies that arise without prior economic developmentsometimes because they are imposed by former colonial powers or international organi. Correlation between democracy and economic development. Scholars need to theorise and assess these differential effects, rather than assume that economic prosperity is a juggernaut that brings all good things in its train. Seymour lipset, some social requisites of democracy 1959 1. Economic development and political legitimacy1 volume 53 issue 1 seymour martin lipset skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. More recent challenges focus on empirical relationships discernible from cross. Lipset s 1959 modernization hypothesis advances that economic development supports democratic institutions. Economic development and political legitimacy, authorseymour martin lipset, year1959 seymour martin lipset. Lipset seymour martin some social requisites of democracy. The field of research that examines the link between democracy and economic development was first popularised by seymour martin lipset in some social requisites of democracy.
Democracy, development, and the international system. Early on, moore and odonnell questioned the logic of the argument. Economic development and democracy lipset s observation that democracy is related to economic development, first advanced in 1959, has generated the largest body of research on any topic in comparative politics. Until quite recently, conventional wisdom has held that economic development, wherever it occurs, will lead inevitably and fairly quickly to democracy. Democracy and economic development adam przeworski. One of the best established results in this field is. Economic development and political legitimacy seymour martin lipset university of california, berkeley the conditions associated with the existence and stability of democratic society. Some scholars argue that economic growth drives social mobilization, which in turn leads to political mobilization and eventually regime change to democracy lipset. On the relation of economic development to democratic. Existing studies of the relationship between economic development and democracy whether they nd support for a positive association between development and democracy or not overlook key conceptual and empirical issues. Yet it is also possible that democracies emerge without any relation to economic development, but that once established for whatever reasons, they survive in developed countries. Paper presented at the seminar democracy versus authoritarianism in the third world, institute of world economy and international relations, moscow. Seymour martin lipset and political sociology archer 2010. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it.
Lipset dubbed economic development a social requisite to democracy, considering factors such as national wealth, a large degree of industrialization, and high levels of education to be necessary fertilizers to prepare a breeding ground for democracy. Economic development and political legitimacy seymour martin lipset university of california, berkeley the conditions associated with the existence and stability of democratic society have been a leading concern of political philosophy. Parameter estimates for economic development and democratic performance. He also wrote extensively about the conditions for democracy in comparative perspective. Income per capita is a narrow definition of economic development in empirical analysis for hypothesis testing. Lipset dubbed economic development a social requisite to democracy, considering factors such as national wealth, a large degree of industrialization, and high levels of education to be necessary fertilizers to prepare a breeding. The social bases of politics is an award winning political science book from 1960 by seymour martin lipset the book is an influential analysis of the bases of democracy across the world. Voluntary associations, civil society and democracy in africa. Following lipset 1959, we assume that economic development involves a. It has been supported and con tested, revised and extended, buried and resuscitated. The most important work on the subject has been done by lipset 1959 where he states that economic development is one of the prerequisites for democracy. Tan since seymour martin lipsets seminal work on the socioeconomic prerequisites of democracy, a substantial number of social scientists has theorized and empirically tested theories about the relationship between democracy and economic develop. These studies assembled a narrow range of aggregate data on development and democracy for many countries, converted them into standardized numerical values, and performed. Seymour martin lipset and political sociology1 archer.
Goldstone and adriana kocornikmina school of public policy, george mason university draft 3105 one of the most discussed topics in comparative politics is the relationship between democracy and economic development. Revisions to lipsets economic theory of democratic. In this paper the problem is attacked from a sociological and behavioral standpoint, by presenting a number of hypotheses concerning some social requisites for democracy, and by discussing some of the data available to test these hypotheses. In recent years lipsets findings have been challenged. Economic development doesnt always lead to democracy. Previous empirical literature focuses on income per capita as a measure for economic development. Seymour martin lipset and political sociology archer. The more welltodo a nation, the greater the chances that it will sustain democracy, said seymour martin lipset in 1959. Lipset and other modernization theorists suggested that increasing education, equality, urbanization, experience of working in factories, and the. Martin lipset s article titled, zsome social requisites of democracy. Economic development and democracy reconsidered larry. This correlation is now widely accepted, and subsequent debate has focused on which causal mechanisms are. Economic development and political legitimacy1 seymour martin lipset university of california, berkeley the conditions associated with the existence and stability of democratic society have been a leading concern of political philosophy.
His most famous summarization was, the morewelltodo a nation, the greater the chance that it will sustain. Fully aware of democratic benefits namely promoting fundamental freedoms, transparency, openness and accountability, this article seeks to highlight arguments that present democracy as a hindrance to economic development this is the lee hypothesis and demonstrate that economic development is a prerequisite for democracy, that is, economic. Seymour martin lipset march 18, 1922 december 31, 2006 was an american sociologist. The notion of economic growth having a greater influence on democracy was a very popular opinion in the 1950s. Apr 02, 2005 the seymour martin lipset lecture on democracy in the world on 6 december 2004, fernando henrique cardoso delivered the first annual seymour martin lipset lecture on democracy in the world at the canadian embassy in washington, d. In some social requisites of democracy, lipset 1959 emphasizes the strong relationship between capitalist economic development and the prospects for democracy, an argument to which he returned in his asa presidential address. Seymour martin lipset, who conjectured that higher levels of economic development and a more equal distribution of. Democracy and economic development adam przeworski department of politics new york university i examine the mutual relation between political regimes and economic development.
His major work was in the fields of political sociology, trade union organization, social stratification, public opinion, and the sociology of intellectual life. We revisit lipsets law, which posits a positive and significant relationship between income and democracy. We revisit lipset s law, which posits a positive and significant relationship between income and democracy. Economic development and political legitimacy authors. The city university of new york democracy and economic development. And do democratic institutions facilitate economic development. Using lipset s modernization hypothesis as our theoretical framework, we contend that this measure does not capture the fundamental quality of economic development and as such may disadvantage low income regions when conducting empirical analysis. In the heyday of modernisation theory it was widely accepted that economic development would favour democracy lipset 1959. In this paper the problem is attacked from a sociological and behavioral.
1287 1105 1342 787 85 146 28 1580 1130 800 1336 362 321 1560 335 585 1522 1313 895 1047 1277 661 1603 859 1192 364 548 1334 627 1158 532 1375 955 914 1102